The Rusty Nail cocktail is said to have originated in the 1960’s at the 21 Club in NYC and was rumored to be heavily enjoyed by the Rat Pack. The first and last time I had a Rusty Nail was in 2008 in Los Angeles at The Dresden Bar made famous from the movie Swingers. I figured since I was in an “old school place” I should have an “old school cocktail”. I remember it being good, but a little too sweet for me. At the time I had just stared drinking whisky on the regular.
Now in 2024 (16 fucking years later….sigh) I re-introduced myself to this old school cocktail and my opinion has not really changed. I used Monkey Shoulder Scotch which is a little on the lighter side so I am wondering how Johnnie Walker Double Black or a peaty whisky would pair with the Drambuie.
The Rusty Nail
- 2 oz Scotch
- 1 oz Drambuie
- Serve on ice
- Orange peel optional
I will try this one again with a stronger whisky. It is not my preference for a cocktail, but I can see this making a nice sweet after dinner drink. However, I would prefer a brandy, cognac, or a very good single malt.
If you like it, drink it! – Chris
If you like it, drink it!
